NYC Fitness Club Melee – Feeling The Burn!
2008
Aerobic Shouting Gets Member A Hospital Visit:
Stuart Sugarman just can’t stop shouting when he trains. He endlessly grunts and shouts the well known cardio-class mantras like “You Go Girl”, “Yeah I Feel The Burn” and other such slogans!
Meanwhile, a stock broker – Christopher Carter, was training nearby and became so irate over this endless grunting and yelping that he attacked Sugarman and allegedly “tipped” him off his exercise bike causing him alleged injuries.
Needless to say Sugarman sued Carter for injuries he sustained and if convicted, Carter could face as much as a year in jail. He told prosecutors that Sugarman’s hollering and aerobics yelps and shouts provoked him into the bike tipping assault.
Meanwhile, Sugarman claims that this is from his aerobics class training that come out of him naturally, and that it gets him charged up and comes out automatically.
That was part of his testimony before a Manhattan jury who will decide if Mr. Carter is guilty or if Mr. Sugarman’s constant grunting and shouting were indeed, cause enough to provoke Carter to “bike tipping” charges.
Many sources claim that Carter warned Sugarman to “shut the f**k up a couple of time and that Sugarman flipped him off and yelled back “why don’t you make me”. After several taunts were exchanged Carter finally pushed Sugarman into the wall while riding the bike.
To add insult to injury, the fitness club revoked Sugarman’s membership. All the while Sugarman was re-habbing in the hospital and claims he received a concussion and had to have surgery to keep him from becoming paralyzed.
We don’t condone this behavior but there’s probably been some comedic moments and thoughts as testimony has been given in this case. Two Manhattan professionals brawling in class while doing something called “spin training” – too much!
If you’re in the Big Apple, you may not want to be grunting and shouting aerobics chants in the gym – you may be intruding on the reflective time of an irate tax broker, who had a bad week on the trading floor, and “spun” out of control. We’ll watch with interest as this unfolds in the court and perhaps follow up on the verdict when it comes down. “Woo-Woo!”
(Sources: too numerous to mention)

Comment